OEM-Certified Collision Repair - Akron-Canton Ohio

$6.8M

Revenue

$1.1M

SDE

5.1x

Multiple

Subscribe Free

Read the full deal writeup

Get Free Access

Already a member? Sign in

Full Editorial Writeup

This is an established OEM-certified collision repair and mechanical service company built from scratch over nearly 30 years in the Akron-Canton, Ohio market. The business carries 14 OEM certifications, offers in-house vehicle calibration, and holds multiple Direct Repair Program (DRP) relationships with major insurance carriers. Those DRP relationships matter because they create a recurring, referral-driven pipeline of insurance-funded collision work, which is far stickier and less price-sensitive than walk-in mechanical repair. The company posts roughly $6.8M in gross revenue with $1.08M in SDE, a solid 15.8% margin for a shop of this size.

Operations run out of a leased 14,400 square foot facility with two paint booths, two wash bays, and dedicated collision and mechanical departments. The build combines high-margin collision work with recurring mechanical service, and the 14 OEM certifications are a genuine barrier to entry given the training, equipment, and manufacturer scrutiny required to earn and maintain them. This positions the shop to capture higher-value repairs on newer, more complex vehicles that independent shops without certifications cannot legally or profitably touch.

The asking price is $5.5M against $1.08M SDE, a 5.07x multiple that sits at the premium end for auto shops but is defensible given the certification moat, DRP relationships, and the manager-in-place structure. The seller is retiring after building the business, and a tenured General Manager is willing to stay, which materially de-risks the transition for a strategic MSO, financial buyer, or first-time operator.

Why we like it

Earnings quality is strong for the category, with $1.08M SDE on $6.8M revenue for a 15.8% margin, driven by insurance-funded collision work rather than discretionary consumer spend. DRP relationships mean carriers steer volume directly to the shop, creating a recurring pipeline that does not depend on marketing spend or local price wars.
The moat is real and hard to replicate. 14 OEM certifications plus in-house calibration require significant capital investment, ongoing training, and manufacturer approval, which legally locks out uncertified competitors from repairing newer vehicles with advanced driver-assistance systems. Nearly 30 years of goodwill and a tenured workforce reinforce that position.
Market tailwinds favor certified collision shops. Vehicles are increasingly loaded with sensors, cameras, and ADAS technology that require OEM-certified repair and calibration, pushing more work toward shops like this one and away from generalists. Collision demand is also insurance-driven and largely recession-resistant since accidents happen regardless of the economy.
The operator advantage here is the manager-in-place structure. A seasoned GM already runs daily operations and is willing to stay, which means a buyer is acquiring a functioning platform rather than a job. This makes the deal viable for an MSO rolling up shops or a financial buyer who wants cash flow without moving to Ohio.
The facility offers embedded upside. The listing notes meaningful opportunity to optimize workflow and increase production capacity within the existing 14,400 square foot footprint, meaning a buyer can grow throughput without immediately taking on new real estate or a second location.

How to improve it

Audit throughput and cycle time in the first 90 days. With two paint booths and existing capacity noted as underutilized, map the bottlenecks in the collision workflow and push cars-per-week higher. Even a 10% improvement in cycle time directly increases revenue with minimal added fixed cost.
Deepen and expand DRP relationships. Quantify the revenue share coming from each insurance carrier partner and pursue additional DRP agreements with carriers not yet in the network. Each new DRP is a recurring lead source that requires no marketing spend and improves booked volume predictability.
Layer in ADAS calibration as a standalone profit center. In-house calibration is already a capability, so market it to other independent shops in the region that lack the equipment and certifications. Charging per-calibration for outside jobs turns a cost center into a high-margin B2B revenue line.
Formalize and document systems ahead of the GM transition. Even though the GM is staying, build standard operating procedures, KPI dashboards, and technician incentive structures so the business is not fragile to the departure of any single person. This protects value and makes a future exit cleaner.
Renegotiate the facility lease or evaluate purchase. Since the building is leased, lock in a long-term lease with favorable renewal terms to protect the location and prevent landlord leverage at renewal. Alternatively, explore buying the real estate to capture rent as equity and add a hard asset to the balance sheet.
Push the mechanical service department utilization. Collision work is lumpy and insurance-driven, but the mechanical bays can generate steadier, higher-frequency revenue. Add service reminders, tire and maintenance packages, and a booking system to fill mechanical capacity between collision jobs.
Use this as an MSO platform anchor. With 14 certifications and an established brand, this shop can serve as the hub for a regional roll-up. Acquire smaller uncertified independents nearby and funnel their complex jobs into this certified facility to lift consolidated margins.

Diligence notes

Verify the durability and transferability of the OEM certifications. Confirm that all 14 certifications survive a change of ownership without recertification lapses, and check the recurring cost and training requirements to maintain them. A certification that expires or requires reapproval on transfer would erode the moat this deal is priced on.
Scrutinize the DRP contracts and revenue concentration. Determine what percentage of revenue flows through each insurance carrier and whether any single DRP represents a dangerous concentration. Confirm these agreements are transferable and are not subject to termination clauses triggered by a sale.
Validate the $1.08M SDE with tax returns and add-back detail. At a 5.07x multiple, the entire thesis rests on that cash flow figure. Reconcile reported SDE against three years of financials and scrutinize owner add-backs, since the retiring founder's true economic contribution needs to be normalized against the GM's salary.
Assess GM retention risk and compensation. The deal leans heavily on the GM staying, so review their comp, tenure, and any retention or incentive agreement. Model what happens to margins if the GM leaves within 12 months and needs to be replaced at market rate.
Review the lease terms carefully given no real estate is included. Confirm remaining lease length, renewal options, rent escalators, and whether the landlord is related to the seller. A short remaining term or above-market rent at renewal could materially change the economics of a specialized, equipment-heavy facility that is expensive to relocate.
Confirm the age and condition of the collision equipment. Paint booths, frame machines, and calibration equipment are capital-intensive and wear out. Get a schedule of major equipment with ages and expected replacement timelines so deferred capex does not surprise you post-close.

Source

Originally listed on BizBuySell. View original listing →